Diskussion:Heuristics: Representation of Search Space and Neighborhoods 2

Comment on the Wikipedia-Entry "Heuristics: Representation of Search Space and Neighborhoods 2"

Hi,

all in all, I think you have done well in general in explaining the idea from the VNS. But I am missing some crucial points alltogether.

First you could have done better formating with your entry. I am missing a directory which can be done with " == " before and after a headline. Overall there are some typos, but that should not be a big problem here.

Your introduction looks good and i think you described the Common principles of heuristics very good.

Your mathematical formulation of the problem seems fine, but as I am not really good with such formulations, I cannot say for sure. It is good to see that you used LaTeX for your formulas.

Your graphical example shows very good what you tried to describe in the "basic idea" section.

Several times, you write "in our example" but i cannot find a real example of yours. So that I am really missing the most. A practical example with actual numbers/ nodes and so on.

Your external links are fine as such, but i cannot find your sources. As we had to credit our sources, they are missing from your entry.

As a conclusion: You described the Heuristics in general and the VNS-Heuristic pretty good, but your wiki-entry misses some crucial points as a directory, formation, an example and sources. Furthermore we would have liked to see a bit more depth into the two mainthemes "Search Space" and "neighborhood".

Greetings,

"Heuristics: Representation of Search Space and Neighborhoods 1"